whats wrong with this card? (new create a card game)

[Ditto]

maybe that it says "target creature" and enchantments dont say "target" usually because thats already implied?

hmmm I guess you are right, but that one was an unitnentional mistake

The real one is still unsolved

[Galaxy]

ok i guess noone knows the answer to my card again

it is that forests are not green they are colorless so when it says green lands you thought it meant forests but its actually wrong because forests are not green lands they are also colorless even though they make green mana

you didnt give enough time to answer again

[Galaxy]

Summoning Academy 1GG
Enchantment
Token creatures you cast cost 1 less

you dont cast tokens

[Crocodile]

maybe it should say "sacrifice an artifact you control" instead of just "sacrifice an artifact" because you can't sacrifice something that you dont control (I read this somewhere else in the forum)

Nope, see:

Arcbound Ravager
atog
Kuldotha Rebirth

(although you are right that you can't sacrifice something you dont control)

[Chodie]

soul injection 1BB
Sorcery
As an additional cost to cast soul injection, sacrifice an artifact.
Return a creature with converted mana cost X from the graveyard to the battlefield, where X is the scarified artifact's converted mana cost.

Is it because it says THE graveyard instead of YOUR graveyard? It sounds like it's going to be a stupid answer. I can honestly say I don't see a problem.

[Chodie]

also you dont discard from your library only from your hand

Bingo!!! Both answers

[Chodie]

Planar reassignment 5UU
Enchantment - Aura
Enchant Creature
you may sacrifice a planeswalker rather then paying Planar reassignment's mana cost
Gain control of target creature. If enchanted creature would be put in the graveyard, return that creature to your hand instead.

It's because once the creature goes to the graveyard the enchantment attached goes too, therefore it's ability can't trigger because the enchantment is in the graveyard.

[Chodie]

Maker of Myths
UU
creature - wizard
T: Target phased out creature gains protection from instants.
1/3

[Ditto]

It's because once the creature goes to the graveyard the enchantment attached goes too, therefore it's ability can't trigger because the enchantment is in the graveyard.

no, if that was it then cards such as Necrotic Plague and Squee's Embrace wouldnt work as well

[Chodie]

Arcbound Artificer
Creature
UUU
Modular 4
0/0

[Chodie]

recuperation 1WGG
enchantment
whenever a creature you control reaches negative toughness, you may pay 1. If you do, regenerate that creature.

ok, ok... I meant to say this. Whats the point of regenerating a creature if it's toughness is below zero? Plus regenerate says if it were to be destroyed, remove the damage and tap it... even if the damage is removed it would still be destroyed.

[Myself]

Maker of Myths
UU
creature - wizard
T: Target phased out creature gains protection from instants.
1/3

you cant have protection from instants?

[kip]

you cant have protection from instants?

Petrified Wood-Kin

[Chodie]

Nope, creatures can have protection from... anything i think. Progenitus DOES have protection from everything.

[Chodie]

yes thats right

here is another one

Planar reassignment 5UU
Enchantment - Aura
Enchant Creature
you may sacrifice a planeswalker rather then paying Planar reassignment's mana cost
Gain control of target creature. If enchanted creature would be put in the graveyard, return that creature to your hand instead.

A couple more (these might be a bit harder)

Lunatic Warrior 1RB
Creature - Human Soldier
When lunatic warrior enters the battlefield, target player discards 3 cards and you lose 3 life
T: The next sorcery spell you cast this turn can't be countered
1/3

soul injection 1BB
Sorcery
As an additional cost to cast soul injection, sacrifice an artifact.
Return a creature with converted mana cost X from the graveyard to the battlefield, where X is the scarified artifact's converted mana cost.

Arcbound Artificer
Creature
UUU
Modular 4
0/0

Maker of Myths
UU
creature - wizard
T: Target phased out creature gains protection from instants.
1/3

None of these have been answered yet...

[Chodie]

Arcbound Artificer
Creature
UUU
Modular 4
0/0

Sorry... I posted this yet it has not problems... that I can see.

[Warrior]

Circle of Protection Trample
1W
Enchantment
1: The next time a creature would deal trample damage, that damage is prevented.

There's no such thing as "Trample damage"?

soul injection 1BB
Sorcery
As an additional cost to cast soul injection, sacrifice an artifact.
Return a creature with converted mana cost X from the graveyard to the battlefield, where X is the scarified artifact's converted mana cost.

in the graveyard its not a creature but a "creature card"?

Planar reassignment 5UU
Enchantment - Aura
Enchant Creature
you may sacrifice a planeswalker rather then paying Planar reassignment's mana cost
Gain control of target creature. If enchanted creature would be put in the graveyard, return that creature to your hand instead.

It has the potential of putting in your hand a card that you do not own?

[Chodie]

Yes, there is no such thing as trample damage. I hate that phrase.

On Soul Injection... I have no idea what the problem is...

On Planar Reassignment, I think you got it, but it may be an unintentional problem.

[Boat]

Haunted Reefs
Land
T, Pay 1 life, Sacrifice Haunted Reefs: Search your deck for a Swamp or Island card and put it onto the battlefield. Then shuffle your library.

[Chodie]

Haunted Reefs
Land
T, Pay 1 life, Sacrifice Haunted Reefs: Search your deck for a Swamp or Island card and put it onto the battlefield. Then shuffle your library.

I don't see the problem with this card...