When I exile a creature with level counters on it, or a planeswalker with loyalty counters, do they keep the counters on them in the exile zone?
When I exile a creature with level counters on it, or a planeswalker with loyalty counters, do they keep the counters on them in the exile zone?
Any permanent that has been removed from the battlefield and comes back again return with the same properties printed on the card, nothing more or less unless the card says so (like otherworldly journey)
In other words, if the card is returned to play, it loses all memory of its previous exist and comes in as though you have just cast it normally. If Ajani Vengeant had 6 counters when he was exiled, he'll return to play with 3.
Fluttershy is best pony.