After landing on Mythology Island, go to the right, past the signs that say "Herc's Hero Hut" and "New Herc Honey Cake" and "Try our Fish Nuggets". There is a woman there that if you talk to her, she says that Hercules is signing autographs today, but she does not say anything else. Another woman with a fruit basket over her head, also is not very talkative and just wishes you that "May the gods watch over you, stranger".

Go a bit to the left, and find a big rock building that says "Museum of Olympus". Enter it. Go to the right. The mural will show a short story about the gods. After the scene ends, keep going right. Jump on a platform and up to the second level, and find a statue with a starfish on its head. Grab the starfish:

Starfish
Twinkle, Twinkle, little star.

Exit the Museum of Olympus and go west, past a sign that says "Tree of Immortality". You reach a forest. There is a sign on the ground, it says "Become a God!" and has an arrow pointing left. Go the direction of the arrow. You run into a woman who tells you that things aren't always what they seem to be. Keep going left, and you come across a sign that says "Eat an Apple!". If you click on a statue nearby, she says that she "double dares you to pick an apple". Climb the stairs, past the sign that says "Pick one now!" and go up the tree.

Use the red snakes to help you climb the tree. You run into a small leprechaun. Ask him if he can help you get the golden apple. He tells you that his Nymphs hid all his honey, and to collect 10 jars before time runs out and he will help you.

This will start a timer, you will have 60 seconds (1 minute) to collect 10 honey jars. Look for them around the tree. If you fail to collect the 10 honey jars on time, you can talk to the small creature to try again. Once you have collected 10 of them, return to the leprechaun. He thanks you for the honey and shows you a secret path to reach the apple.

Jump onto the secret path that has just been uncovered, and walk on the branch, then cause the Golden Apple to fall down. Jump after it, and you receive:

Golden Apple
The Fruit of the Gods